The Secret Ingredient (Marmalade) Part II: Creamcicle Ice Cream with Chocolate Chunks

RECIPE: Marmalade and Chocolate Ice Cream
Marmalade Ice Cream

Marmalade and Chocolate Ice Cream

Get the whole story at Serious Eats.

Marmalade is a preserve made of citrus fruits, usually studded with the bitter rind of the fruit itself. While it can be made of lemons or limes, grapefruits or clementines, the traditional marmalade uses the Seville orange (although the best one I’ve ever had was made from oranges and tangerines, making it just slightly sweeter).

Marmalade is one of those polarizing ingredients: either you love it and smother your toast with it, or its bitter-sweetness makes your tongue shrivel in protest. The Secret Ingredient‘s marmalade recipes are a compromise. I can’t promote just bitter-sweet jam on toast, but to overlook the complexity of marmalade in different applications is just as foolhardy. The texture makes it perfect for thick sauces like in last week’s Orange Peel Shrimp. And its warring bitterness and sweetness adds such depth to the otherwise very sweet chocolate chip ice cream in this recipe.

I don’t know what could go better with orange than vanilla or chocolate, so why not throw in both? A very vanilla ice cream studded with dark chocolate gets a ribbon of runny marmalade throughout it, adding creamsicle sweetness and candied orange rind bitterness all at once. The result is unexpected, sophisticated, and simple. Perfect if you want to impress, or just make sneaky trips to the freezer for some scoops (just like with any other ice cream).

Marmalade and Chocolate Ice Cream
serves 6

Marmalade Ice CreamIngredients

  • 1 cup milk, cold

  • 3/4 cup granulated sugar

  • Pinch fine sea salt

  • 2 cups heavy cream, cold

  • 1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract

  • 1/2 cup orange marmalade (recommended: Bonne Maman)

  • 1 3/4 ounces 70% cocoa dark chocolate, cut into small chunks


Chill you ice cream maker’s bowl overnight.

In a large bowl, whisk together the milk, sugar, and salt with a hand mixer on high speed until the sugar is dissolved.  Add the cream and vanilla extract, and whisk to combine.

Turn on your ice cream maker, and pour in the cream mixture.  Depending on your machine, the ice cream should be ready in about 20 minutes.

Place the marmalade in a small saucepot over medium-low heat and heat just to loosen its texture.  You don’t want it too hot: just pourable.

1 minute before your ice cream is due to be ready, add in the chocolate chunks.  Once the chocolate is thoroughly combined into the ice cream, steadily stream in the marmalade (don’t pour it in all at once), and allow the machine to just distribute it as ribbons through the ice cream.  Stop the machine before the marmalade gets completely combined with the ice cream.

Transfer the ice cream to a large Tupperware, and freeze for 4 hours.

print this recipe
print this post
Categories: Chocolate, Desserts, Eat, Frozen, Recipes, Series, The Secret Ingredient, Vegetarian

One Response to The Secret Ingredient (Marmalade) Part II: Creamcicle Ice Cream with Chocolate Chunks

  1. Pingback: How to Feed the Fourth: A Round-Up of Easy, Delicious, and Maybe-a-Little-Bit-French Recipes for Independence Day | French Revolution